This has been here since I got the car, and it's kinda bugging me. Can I take out this cap and try to bend it back into place? Or maybe I'd just buy a new one.

But my main question is how to I take it out without breaking anything?

 

subd

 

if i remember correctly its just like a plastic emblem sticker, just pry it off with a lil screw driver and get a new one.
edit: yep

 

If I pry it off, it (or a new one) will go back in nicely?

 

im fairly certain its just a flat emblemso it would be just about lining it up right

 

or just get an overlay like i did lol i tried to wrap mine in vinyl and cut the bowtie in 2 so got an overlay check out Making it Digital thats where i got mine

 

you just take a hook pry tool stick it in there and pull it out. i got one from motor city vinyl