Z54 or Z57
#51
Junior Member
Thread Starter
It's still running just fine, haven't put my summer tires on yet, Colorado likes to sneak in a late snow sometimes and life has been a little crazy. I'd have to look at how many miles I've put on the turbo so far, it doesn't get a lot of WOT pulls during the winter but it still gets 12-15psi rolled in multiple times a week.
I'll add to this thread, and say go with the Z57
I bought one of the first Z54's, and it grenaded in 10k miles, most of which was all highway mileage (drove for work temporarily and had work logs for proof). After a bit of a fiasco with a bunch of other units detonating, they warrantied them all and added whatever improvements they found from the failures. Warranty unit was installed early 2018.
Here we go earlier today that one bit the dust. Merging onto the highway I had it around 10psi when I was suddenly greeted with a clunk, loss of boost, and the sound of a hair dryer. Babied it home, pulled the intake, and the bearings are completely fried. This unit has over 10k, need to double check mileages.
Fortunately, oil looked clean, filter didn't really have many fines, and there doesn't seem to be anything that made it past that first 90* off the turbo.
Edit: Should check my exhaust and see if I have a turbine wheel in it
I bought one of the first Z54's, and it grenaded in 10k miles, most of which was all highway mileage (drove for work temporarily and had work logs for proof). After a bit of a fiasco with a bunch of other units detonating, they warrantied them all and added whatever improvements they found from the failures. Warranty unit was installed early 2018.
Here we go earlier today that one bit the dust. Merging onto the highway I had it around 10psi when I was suddenly greeted with a clunk, loss of boost, and the sound of a hair dryer. Babied it home, pulled the intake, and the bearings are completely fried. This unit has over 10k, need to double check mileages.
Fortunately, oil looked clean, filter didn't really have many fines, and there doesn't seem to be anything that made it past that first 90* off the turbo.
Edit: Should check my exhaust and see if I have a turbine wheel in it
#52
Senior Member
Damn sorry to hear that I remember reading your houston we have a problem thread which has made me hesitant to get those vs a reliable borgwarner turbo. I know the Z57 has a ball bearing and I haven't heard of any failures so maybe that design is truly more reliable than the Z54s.
I may rebuild it with a supercore, but I haven't decided where to go with it yet. Need to wait for my bonus in July before I have spare cash, so I have time to plan it out.
#53
Junior Member
Thread Starter
Yeah, definitely not going to get another in house from them. I was tempted to get a Z57, but I still don't know after these two.
I may rebuild it with a supercore, but I haven't decided where to go with it yet. Need to wait for my bonus in July before I have spare cash, so I have time to plan it out.
I may rebuild it with a supercore, but I haven't decided where to go with it yet. Need to wait for my bonus in July before I have spare cash, so I have time to plan it out.
#54
Rattlesnake Race Shop
iTrader: (1)
That's a biiiggg turbo. Anyone know someone that has ran an S257? I can't imagine that thing spools in any sort of timely manner. I know the older S259's were laggy as all hell.
I think I remember S252 guys being in the 3500 to 4000 rpm range for full boost. Tuning obviously plays a large roll.
I think I remember S252 guys being in the 3500 to 4000 rpm range for full boost. Tuning obviously plays a large roll.
#55
Junior Member
Thread Starter
That's a biiiggg turbo. Anyone know someone that has ran an S257? I can't imagine that thing spools in any sort of timely manner. I know the older S259's were laggy as all hell.
I think I remember S252 guys being in the 3500 to 4000 rpm range for full boost. Tuning obviously plays a large roll.
I think I remember S252 guys being in the 3500 to 4000 rpm range for full boost. Tuning obviously plays a large roll.
#56
I am just waiting to send ZZP my ECU so they can send my gaskets needed for install then I'll give you a honest review.
ZZP Z54 BNIB
The following users liked this post:
AfterShok (05-26-2021)
The following users liked this post:
DeanSsspsh (05-25-2021)
#58
Senior Member
iTrader: (3)
That's a biiiggg turbo. Anyone know someone that has ran an S257? I can't imagine that thing spools in any sort of timely manner. I know the older S259's were laggy as all hell.
I think I remember S252 guys being in the 3500 to 4000 rpm range for full boost. Tuning obviously plays a large roll.
I think I remember S252 guys being in the 3500 to 4000 rpm range for full boost. Tuning obviously plays a large roll.
then there is my best bud Bluelightning. He on an lsj though. Def a bit laggy. But that’s coming from a 252 which was more responsive but would fall off at like 6k
the 257 takes it right to 8k at 30psi. Pulls very hard. Can’t have it all. An efr would be a better option for those running an lnf and wanting to make over 400whp.
im happy with my z54. I’m at the limits of traction in second gear with the boost ramped and turnt down a touch. I like having some bottom end. 6758 is definitely better all around but you gotta $$$ to play.
I just wanted something with a bit more potential and my stock turbo died.
I do miss super low end torque in traffic but it’s not exactly laggy. But at least 70-100 more whp and pulls right to 6500rpm (probably higher if head work was done) it’s a great balance.
Next car won’t be a turbo 4banger that’s for sure!
The following users liked this post:
AfterShok (05-23-2021)
#59
Junior Member
Thread Starter
I went Z54 since they just got the Z57 back in stock recently and I didn't want to miss the season lol. I wanted to go Z57 but decided that I am going with a tubular manifold set up later so the Z54 will get me by for now. I have 2 ECUs so I'll have a 93 pump tune for mini road trips and the other will be my E47 tune.
I am just waiting to send ZZP my ECU so they can send my gaskets needed for install then I'll give you a honest review.
ZZP Z54 BNIB
I am just waiting to send ZZP my ECU so they can send my gaskets needed for install then I'll give you a honest review.
ZZP Z54 BNIB
Me too i've been on and off but I am back for good
there is 2 cars I know of running a 257 in my area. Ones tomj77 (haven’t seen his car since he went full out with the build. Not sure what it’s spool characteristics are like on an lnf.
then there is my best bud Bluelightning. He on an lsj though. Def a bit laggy. But that’s coming from a 252 which was more responsive but would fall off at like 6k
the 257 takes it right to 8k at 30psi. Pulls very hard. Can’t have it all. An efr would be a better option for those running an lnf and wanting to make over 400whp.
im happy with my z54. I’m at the limits of traction in second gear with the boost ramped and turnt down a touch. I like having some bottom end. 6758 is definitely better all around but you gotta $$$ to play.
I just wanted something with a bit more potential and my stock turbo died.
I do miss super low end torque in traffic but it’s not exactly laggy. But at least 70-100 more whp and pulls right to 6500rpm (probably higher if head work was done) it’s a great balance.
Next car won’t be a turbo 4banger that’s for sure!
then there is my best bud Bluelightning. He on an lsj though. Def a bit laggy. But that’s coming from a 252 which was more responsive but would fall off at like 6k
the 257 takes it right to 8k at 30psi. Pulls very hard. Can’t have it all. An efr would be a better option for those running an lnf and wanting to make over 400whp.
im happy with my z54. I’m at the limits of traction in second gear with the boost ramped and turnt down a touch. I like having some bottom end. 6758 is definitely better all around but you gotta $$$ to play.
I just wanted something with a bit more potential and my stock turbo died.
I do miss super low end torque in traffic but it’s not exactly laggy. But at least 70-100 more whp and pulls right to 6500rpm (probably higher if head work was done) it’s a great balance.
Next car won’t be a turbo 4banger that’s for sure!
The following users liked this post:
ionRL_585 (05-24-2021)
#61
The following users liked this post:
ionRL_585 (05-25-2021)
#64
Rattlesnake Race Shop
iTrader: (1)
I've been contemplating swapping to one... I want something more responsive down low.
I'd love to move to a GT2871RS... but that would require changing my downpipe setup, and I'm not sure I want to do that much work.
#66
Junior Member
Thread Starter
#67
Senior Member
I'm contemplating doing a supercore if I can, otherwise most likely an actual EFR.
The following 2 users liked this post by Tdubbs:
AfterShok (05-26-2021),
DeanSsspsh (05-25-2021)
#68
Z57
Well Im new here and i wanted to try and get as much Info as I can . i just bought the z57 and i was looking to get like 400 - 420hp out of my Bolt with stock motor is this achievable or do i need to change the valve springs or would i be fine ? i have full bolt ons and plan on setting up a dyno tune after installed
#69
Junior Member
Thread Starter
Well Im new here and i wanted to try and get as much Info as I can . i just bought the z57 and i was looking to get like 400 - 420hp out of my Bolt with stock motor is this achievable or do i need to change the valve springs or would i be fine ? i have full bolt ons and plan on setting up a dyno tune after installed
Last edited by AfterShok; 05-26-2021 at 03:07 AM.
#70
Senior Member
iTrader: (3)
Does he still have that S252 lying around? What RPM did it start coming alive?
I've been contemplating swapping to one... I want something more responsive down low.
I'd love to move to a GT2871RS... but that would require changing my downpipe setup, and I'm not sure I want to do that much work.
I've been contemplating swapping to one... I want something more responsive down low.
I'd love to move to a GT2871RS... but that would require changing my downpipe setup, and I'm not sure I want to do that much work.
Last edited by slapbetcommissioner; 05-26-2021 at 05:13 AM.
#71
Senior Member
iTrader: (3)
Well Im new here and i wanted to try and get as much Info as I can . i just bought the z57 and i was looking to get like 400 - 420hp out of my Bolt with stock motor is this achievable or do i need to change the valve springs or would i be fine ? i have full bolt ons and plan on setting up a dyno tune after installed
Going higher than 400whp will be getting close to maxing out your stock fuel system. There is fixes for that (meth being one of them)
the motor itself is fairly safe to mid 4’s some hit 500 with a good
tune and good fuel.
valve springs and zzp fuel cam can get you there (may has well go stage 2 cams if you go that route)
Last edited by slapbetcommissioner; 05-26-2021 at 05:19 AM.
#72
Senior Member
iTrader: (3)
I didn’t bother trying to video it as it’s hard to get the tac and boost in one shot. But I did some testing on the way to work. Basically from 1800rpm in vacuum. Rolling (not stomping on) it hits 5psi by about 2900rpm and that’s when you start to feel it. Shoots right up from there. Makes okay torque from about 2k (no ko4 thoigh hah)
its ramped smooth a little bit at my request to my tuner. I’m sure it could be made to spool slightly faster.
its ramped smooth a little bit at my request to my tuner. I’m sure it could be made to spool slightly faster.
The following users liked this post:
ionRL_585 (06-08-2021)
#75
Rattlesnake Race Shop
iTrader: (1)
That was my thought too - the alleged cooler burn. I do have a DEI Titanium turbo blanket and fully wrapped exhaust from turbo to tail pipe and my EGT's aren't really low though. My browsing of the internet seemed to indicate that E "should" spool faster since you have more of it, the O2 that's in it, and some other BS - but I'm not sure I trust/believe any of it, because most of what I've seen has been random people on forums.
I run a decent amount of timing on spool up (starts out in the 40's and tapers down to mid-20's); I'm sure it could be improved - I mostly just concentrated on AFR during my tuning phase.
I run a decent amount of timing on spool up (starts out in the 40's and tapers down to mid-20's); I'm sure it could be improved - I mostly just concentrated on AFR during my tuning phase.