If you have summers then I would say get winters.
That said, I run uhp all-seasons, always have, and I've never once had an issue.
You just gotta know how to drive in the snow.
I've driven in 17 winters so far. The one issue I've ever had was someone else unable to control their car.

 

YouTube - Pirelli Winter Snowsport - Pneumatiky.cz

 

If your in an area where it snows a lot and is very cold then all seasons don't really cut it. They are ok in areas with little snow but in areas where it gets too cold they start to loose traction

 

I have had issues with my integra all seasons, but that was once and I stopped on a hill and couldn't get going again. Some guy in a truck behind me got out and pushed me and that's all it took.

But I do care about my cobalt more for some reason.

 

all seasons are just not the same as winter tires in inclement weather

 

I'd get dedicated snow tires. I bought some last year after getting stuck and being late to work numerous times and it actually made me looking forward to driving around in the snow.