Best IAT2s?
Actually.. wrong...
If your just going to run it through the stock HE first, then theres no point in having it.. considering it is now not getting any fresh air (just a whole bunch of hot air) and it isnt getting ANY direct flow, what so ever... so its actually keeping your coolant hotter...
PM lsjwannabe, he actually tested this out.
If your just going to run it through the stock HE first, then theres no point in having it.. considering it is now not getting any fresh air (just a whole bunch of hot air) and it isnt getting ANY direct flow, what so ever... so its actually keeping your coolant hotter...
PM lsjwannabe, he actually tested this out.
Last edited by ShortStack; Feb 10, 2009 at 11:57 PM. Reason: Automerged Doublepost
Actually.. wrong...
If your just going to run it through the stock HE first, then theres no point in having it.. considering it is now not getting any fresh air (just a whole bunch of hot air) and it isnt getting ANY direct flow, what so ever... so its actually keeping your coolant hotter...
PM lsjwannabe, he actually tested this out.
If your just going to run it through the stock HE first, then theres no point in having it.. considering it is now not getting any fresh air (just a whole bunch of hot air) and it isnt getting ANY direct flow, what so ever... so its actually keeping your coolant hotter...
PM lsjwannabe, he actually tested this out.
Before you say it, im well aware of lsjwannabe's test results.
its not the aftermarket he making the heat.
Its now that the only air the stock h/e is seeing is air thats coming off of a very hot engine.
And that hot air keeps the stock h/e warm itself.
Its now that the only air the stock h/e is seeing is air thats coming off of a very hot engine.
And that hot air keeps the stock h/e warm itself.
Last edited by ShortStack; Feb 11, 2009 at 02:53 PM. Reason: Automerged Doublepost
^^ it's no different than a stock setup though. To argue that the stock HE doesnt perform any cooling due to its location would be to say that even a stock SS shouldnt have come equipped with the HE and it should just be an un-intercooled setup, which we both know isn't the case.
how does that have anything to do with it...
and yes it is diffferent that a stock setup.. you added an extra HE.. so its no longer stock, and now its different.
Im sayin the stock he doesnt do anything in the location its in because now theres no cool air flowing to it due to the aftermarket HE.
and yes it is diffferent that a stock setup.. you added an extra HE.. so its no longer stock, and now its different.
Im sayin the stock he doesnt do anything in the location its in because now theres no cool air flowing to it due to the aftermarket HE.
how does that have anything to do with it...
and yes it is diffferent that a stock setup.. you added an extra HE.. so its no longer stock, and now its different.
Im sayin the stock he doesnt do anything in the location its in because now theres no cool air flowing to it due to the aftermarket HE.
and yes it is diffferent that a stock setup.. you added an extra HE.. so its no longer stock, and now its different.
Im sayin the stock he doesnt do anything in the location its in because now theres no cool air flowing to it due to the aftermarket HE.
If you were going faster, then the air might only heat up to 72*. Regardless, this 72* air will still be cooler than the stock HE will e, so it will still be cooling the unit. Just because the air has passed through the new HE does not mean that it is now 120* air that is unsuitable to cool anything else off, or else our radiators wouldt work at all because theyre also behind the HE system...Hell, theyre behind BOTH HE's too..
I realize the radiator is a lot hotter than the HE will get, but the same principles apply.
agreed the temp wouldnt be like 10,000*..
But what is the temp of the stock HE now? Alot higher than normal. but that air wont stay at "72*" because there is now hot air trapped which is warming the air more...
If the stock h/e got the same amount of flow as the aftermarket, it would be a different story.. but near non of that air is moving now, deffinatly not at the same pace as it was before.
But what is the temp of the stock HE now? Alot higher than normal. but that air wont stay at "72*" because there is now hot air trapped which is warming the air more...
If the stock h/e got the same amount of flow as the aftermarket, it would be a different story.. but near non of that air is moving now, deffinatly not at the same pace as it was before.
the speed will be slowed, but not much. Go outside, run your AC and the recirculation so the cooling fan turns on. Stick your hand in front of the radiator and then stick it behind the radiator. You will feel a difference, but not a big one...and that fan is probably only the equivalent to cruising around 10mph. The air doesnt get trapped either. It leaves the same way it did before you put an aftermarket HE on
the speed will be slowed, but not much. Go outside, run your AC and the recirculation so the cooling fan turns on. Stick your hand in front of the radiator and then stick it behind the radiator. You will feel a difference, but not a big one...and that fan is probably only the equivalent to cruising around 10mph. The air doesnt get trapped either. It leaves the same way it did before you put an aftermarket HE on
What I have found from messing with timing and IAT2s is that:
1) of course the cooler the air the more timing you can run.
2) about 130F you really have to start retarding the timing alot due to knock on a fairly aggressive tune
3) your AFR also plays a big part as to how much knock you get at different IAT2s
I hate threads like this. There are so many different variables that effect IAT2s that it is retarded to compare one car to another. IAT2 temps are thrown around this forum way too often with little understand of what they actually mean.
This thread is a great example of it.
There are guys posting numbers from SCs, Turbos, Meth, Dual Pass, additional cooling mods, etc.
Unless you have the exact same setup and all environmental variables are the same (Ambient air temp, humidity, elevation, engine run time, tune AFR, tune timing) it does not mean anything from one car to another.
I think E85 is the best cooling mod to run on a SC'd engine. But E85 does not produce as low of IAT2s as say Meth injection. Does that make meth injection better? Hell no!!!
IAT2s are measure by the MAP sensor located on the top left side of the IM. When you spray meth injection it is sprayed into the SC and through the IM. Its safe the say that the vapors from the Meth Injection pass by the MAP sensors effecting is IAT2s temps.
E85 is injected into the cylider head after the IM and after the MAP sensor. So its cooling benefits are not shown in IAT2s.
Exhaust Gas Temps (EGTs) is a much better tool to compare how well the entire combustion process is performing. Not just how well the IM is being cooled.
Bottom line...The lower the IAT2s the better.
This thread is a great example of it.
There are guys posting numbers from SCs, Turbos, Meth, Dual Pass, additional cooling mods, etc.
Unless you have the exact same setup and all environmental variables are the same (Ambient air temp, humidity, elevation, engine run time, tune AFR, tune timing) it does not mean anything from one car to another.
I think E85 is the best cooling mod to run on a SC'd engine. But E85 does not produce as low of IAT2s as say Meth injection. Does that make meth injection better? Hell no!!!
IAT2s are measure by the MAP sensor located on the top left side of the IM. When you spray meth injection it is sprayed into the SC and through the IM. Its safe the say that the vapors from the Meth Injection pass by the MAP sensors effecting is IAT2s temps.
E85 is injected into the cylider head after the IM and after the MAP sensor. So its cooling benefits are not shown in IAT2s.
Exhaust Gas Temps (EGTs) is a much better tool to compare how well the entire combustion process is performing. Not just how well the IM is being cooled.
Bottom line...The lower the IAT2s the better.
Last edited by ebristol; May 4, 2010 at 01:03 PM. Reason: Automerged Doublepost
So don't go 160. You know? You don't have to do a 4th gear pull up to redline. Do a 2nd gear pull, or a 3rd gear pull. Or just keep it into boost, then get out of it for a few seconds, then get back into it so it wouldn't have enough time to cool down so you could see what/how your IAT2's change.


