I'm thinking I should start a build thread. Guess this is it.
#577
I thought about how much it would cost, and it is a decent amount for me. i figured i could keep getting new transmissions and breaking them, which would cost me a lot more, i could tune for lower power, which with these transmissions to avoid breaking u basically have to go down to mid 300s or they will eventually break, or just sell the car, i didn't like these options cause i love my car, and i put a lot of time into it, and i want to see my goals through, so only option was to do it right. it just takes time and a lot of overtime at work to do it, so i am doing it. I'm done doing things in a rush and half assed like i did it in the past with mods. this one is getting done right. if it has to sit in the garage for 2 years to be able to do it right then so be it .
#583
Got Bewst?
iTrader: (8)
I thought about how much it would cost, and it is a decent amount for me. i figured i could keep getting new transmissions and breaking them, which would cost me a lot more, i could tune for lower power, which with these transmissions to avoid breaking u basically have to go down to mid 300s or they will eventually break, or just sell the car, i didn't like these options cause i love my car, and i put a lot of time into it, and i want to see my goals through, so only option was to do it right. it just takes time and a lot of overtime at work to do it, so i am doing it. I'm done doing things in a rush and half assed like i did it in the past with mods. this one is getting done right. if it has to sit in the garage for 2 years to be able to do it right then so be it .
#584
Junior Member
Thats what he had and broke. I'm also running a 4.05 on my setup on e47 now, I know it's not going to last forever, but I rarely ever do 3rd gear pulls unless I have to. Mine has a lot of bearing noise when coasting, but it always did, I'm not even sure 4.45 would hold up to our power for the long run. Only true solution is fully built trans for reliability.
#585
I had a 4.05 it blew up in a month on s257. U will blow ure up eventually. And then ull get another and by the time you realize u need something stronger you will have spent enough money to buy something that won't break. The reason you're is lasting is because ur lsj makes like 100 less tq than my ldk most likely is. Ur making stock turbo with a tune tq. If I was only making that it would have lasted.
#586
Thats what he had and broke. I'm also running a 4.05 on my setup on e47 now, I know it's not going to last forever, but I rarely ever do 3rd gear pulls unless I have to. Mine has a lot of bearing noise when coasting, but it always did, I'm not even sure 4.45 would hold up to our power for the long run. Only true solution is fully built trans for reliability.
#588
Its not, I make sure the torque is reasonable. Didn't save my trans with the zfr with around 400 either. I'm not gonna turn my car into a honda though. Trans should be able to take it, thats why I went for built. Cause I don't want to neuter the car. I want it to be able to take the amount of torque it should be able to. But I guess we see it differently ur satisfied with urs , I want some more not for a number , don't really care about bragging rights, but for the pleasure of feeling it when I lut my foot to the floor.
Last edited by tomj77; 08-06-2017 at 02:49 PM.
#589
Thats what he had and broke. I'm also running a 4.05 on my setup on e47 now, I know it's not going to last forever, but I rarely ever do 3rd gear pulls unless I have to. Mine has a lot of bearing noise when coasting, but it always did, I'm not even sure 4.45 would hold up to our power for the long run. Only true solution is fully built trans for reliability.
#590
Junior Member
#591
Got Bewst?
iTrader: (8)
Its not, I make sure the torque is reasonable. Didn't save my trans with the zfr with around 400 either. I'm not gonna turn my car into a honda though. Trans should be able to take it, thats why I went for built. Cause I don't want to neuter the car. I want it to be able to take the amount of torque it should be able to. But I guess we see it differently ur satisfied with urs , I want some more not for a number , don't really care about bragging rights, but for the pleasure of feeling it when I lut my foot to the floor.
But if ya wanna make it rain by all means haha. Was just a friendly suggestion.
#592
Senior Member
Its not, I make sure the torque is reasonable. Didn't save my trans with the zfr with around 400 either. I'm not gonna turn my car into a honda though. Trans should be able to take it, thats why I went for built. Cause I don't want to neuter the car. I want it to be able to take the amount of torque it should be able to. But I guess we see it differently ur satisfied with urs , I want some more not for a number , don't really care about bragging rights, but for the pleasure of feeling it when I lut my foot to the floor.
Its not about a peak number that makes or breaks a transmission. It's all about how you have it tuned that makes or breaks it. You don't need to "neuter" the car to make it fast and reliable without spending an obscene amount of money.
But if ya wanna make it rain by all means haha. Was just a friendly suggestion.
But if ya wanna make it rain by all means haha. Was just a friendly suggestion.
#594
Senior Member
iTrader: (6)
Is the Quaife 6 speed gears really that strong? Would they be on par with the strength of a f40? Also, what do you do about the shifter? Thanks! Very interesting thread. I absolutely hate my 1st gear. I have 4.45's even so I feel like I'm using granny gear in an old 4x4
My quaife Six speed builds will transfer that torque spike every time without breaking a sweat. As a matter of fact, the stock gearset has the ability to handle it as well. The tq spikes and hard hitting tunes are not the underlying issue. The main issues starts with build quality and/or high-milage wear and ends with a very sharp stress concentration on the 3rd drive gear caused by shaft movement/separation on an already misaligned driven gear. The good news is, those issue have already been remedied with custom parts.
Don't worry about the torque down low. Bring it in as fast at you want or until you start blowing the tires off. It's fine
Obscene amount of money? Lol I don't think you really grasping what he's getting. It is the strongest and likely the most efficient manual ecotec transmission ever in existence. And that's just one of the benefits.
Don't worry about the torque down low. Bring it in as fast at you want or until you start blowing the tires off. It's fine
Obscene amount of money? Lol I don't think you really grasping what he's getting. It is the strongest and likely the most efficient manual ecotec transmission ever in existence. And that's just one of the benefits.
#595
Senior Member
Yes, with my reinforced bellhousing, and other proprietary parts and modifications, it's the strongest manual Ecotec delta trans available, so stronger than F40.
#597
Senior Member
iTrader: (3)
Originally Posted by cw383
Is the Quaife 6 speed gears really that strong? Would they be on par with the strength of a f40? Also, what do you do about the shifter? Thanks! Very interesting thread. I absolutely hate my 1st gear. I have 4.45's even so I feel like I'm using granny gear in an old 4x4
#598
Senior Member
iTrader: (3)
I thought the quaife 6spd had 15% physically smaller gears made of the same metal. Wouldn't that make them weaker? Is there a fundamentally different design to them over the 5 spd? I.e. Most stress at the center of the shaft. Gear with most load and most traction and the least support still being the breaking point?
#599
I thought the quaife 6spd had 15% physically smaller gears made of the same metal. Wouldn't that make them weaker? Is there a fundamentally different design to them over the 5 spd? I.e. Most stress at the center of the shaft. Gear with most load and most traction and the least support still being the breaking point?